South Peace Historical Society

    • Home
    • About / Contact Us
    • About Dorthea Horton
    • About This Collection
    • Bibliography
    • Brief History of the Peace
    • Credits
    • South Peace Historical Society Archives (External Link)
  • Table of Contents

    • Part 1: First Nations of the Peace River Region
    • Part 2: The Fur Trade Era
    • Part 3: Transportation and Communication
    • Part 4: Old Timers and the Price of Land
    • Part 5: Dawson Creek: The Story of the Community
    • Part 6: Mysteries, Adventures and Indian Legends
    • Part 7: Arts, Crafts and Recreation
    • Part 8: Agriculture
    • Part 9: Church Histories
    • Part 10: Schools
    • Part 11: Health Care
    • Part 12: Industries and Enterprises
    • Part 13: Policing the Peace
    • Part 14: Pouce Coupe, Rolla, and Other South Peace Communities
    • Part 15: Chetwynd and the Fort St. John Area
    • Part 16: The Alberta Peace
    • Part 17: Natural History of the Peace River Region
    • Part 18: Interviews with Old Timers
    • Part 19: Remembering Our Veterans

  •  

01-003: Comment on Content of Articles on Indian Origins

by Dorthea Calverley

Several readers of this division have pointed out that I approached this subject of Indian origins in a somewhat illogical and contradictory fashion. I would like to make it clear that that is precisely what I intended to do because it is a reflection of the most learned thinking on the subject. The question of the origin of the Indian peoples and of their sojourn on these American continents is not solved, even though the Bering Sea approach has enough coincidental evidence to warrant its being set down as fact in many books. Actually it was a well-supported hypothesis until some recent events and discoveries disclosed that it may be no more the complete truth than the statement that all native Indians before or after the white man arrived had straight black hair, coppery skins, and brown eyes.

Thinking on the subject ranges through many phases. For some reason, the white man assumed that the Indian must have come from somewhere else. Many educated Indians believe, through oral tradition, that “they were always here” and did not come from some other place. Therefore I have selected articles representative of various views. If as reported in 1974, Clovis points have been found in the Peace River bed, and just possibly a Sandia or Sandia-like point on the shore of Moberly Lake, then another element of timing will modify thinking.

My purpose is quite simple, in this, as in succeeding topics. I draw no hard-and-fast conclusions. If I appear to do so, I am sorry. I am leaving it to the reader to take what to him becomes his “truth,” while being aware that the last word has not been said.

Also one must accept the fact that the findings of modern archeologists may upset any theory. For example are these totally insignificant facts? Indians of unmixed lineage do not have B-type blood. Most Indians have dry, flaky earwax instead of the white man’s moist, sticky kind. Such discoveries open up new approaches. Much new information has been brought to light since these articles were first written, and that fact should be taken into account by anyone beginning a study of the origins of the first humans in North America. This and following apparently contradictory articles are intended as material for a start on independent research, and not as the final word.

In fact, I have, on occasion, deliberately introduced controversial material, not because of personal opinion or conviction, but to develop the idea that there are, frequently, if not always, two sides to any situation.

« 01-002: Daniel Harmon – A Sensitive Observer

01-004: Nine Prehistoric Invasions Near Bering Strait »

© 2023 South Peace Historical Society. All Rights Reserved.